Although Scizor does have only one huge weakness being fire, it's a bit too rampant across a board of effective users to neglect as a factor. Switching into a Bullet Punch or Bug Bite with a number of Pokemon that uses fire moves could prove to be an issue for Scizor depending on Scizor's partner where if Scizor chooses to respond by swapping out against an incoming fire attack, especially if there's sun, chances are that Scizor will end up doing less than what the incoming fire would do in more given situations, and noting that it doesn't have to be a spread fire move either.Scizor remains in A rank.
Great defensive typing, very strong priority that renders Scizor independent on speed support. It has many options for its third moveslot - it's a good Swords Dance user which coincidentally helps against the opponent switching to abuse Intimidate, it's one of the best Feint users, and it can also run moves for surprise KOs like Superpower, Aerial Ace, and Thief, or use Tailwind for team support. It's also one of the best Pokemon at checking very important Pokemon - Cresselia, Tyranitar, Togekiss, Syvleon, Gardevoir, Terrakion, Kyurem-B and more. Compared to Escavalier, it can carry out more roles and is less dependent on team support thanks to Bullet Punch mitigating its Speed issues.
You're right in saying that a Fire-type weakness is a big weakness considering how common Fire-types are. Ideally, Scizor should be on the field with a partner that can handle Fire-types like Terrakion. If you do have two Pokemon out on the field weak to Fire-types at the same time, be prepared to switch out one of them asap as your opponent would probably bring in his Fire type. Also, I can take advantage of Fire-type attacks being aimed at Scizor and switch in my answer to Fire-types at the same time, like Suicune or Heatran, just like switching in a Fire-type to check Scizor. Or if I'm really desperate to handle Fire-types, gimmicky Natural Gift exists, but I wouldn't recommend that option. Considering Scizor has only one weakness, it is easier to pair it with a Pokemon that can handle Scizor's weakness compared to most other Pokemon; try doing so with Abomasnow.Although Scizor does have only one huge weakness being fire, it's a bit too rampant across a board of effective users to neglect as a factor. Switching into a Bullet Punch or Bug Bite with a number of Pokemon that uses fire moves could prove to be an issue for Scizor depending on Scizor's partner where if Scizor chooses to respond by swapping out against an incoming fire attack, especially if there's sun, chances are that Scizor will end up doing less than what the incoming fire would do in more given situations, and noting that it doesn't have to be a spread fire move either.
I wouldn't really take Intimidate into consideration as an ability holding Scizor back since Intimidate applies to most physical users out there anyways. Surprise can be a factor, but when playing in any best out of 3 rounds it's not really something that could be worth mentioning.
As you noted Scizor can effectively take on particular Pokemon, assuming they don't take advantage of the fact as well.
There is so much wrong with this paragraph, I am hemorrhaging IQ points.Even though Landorus also does it, Flygon IS immune to Earthquake thanks to Levitate, but it also gets a better defensive typing for the metagame. For example, it quad-resists Heat Wave and normal-resists Rock Slide. Specially, it learns attacks such as the single-targetting Earth Power and Draco Meteor for a quick nuke on something like Charizard-Y, and my favourite set to use with Flygon is actually Choice Specs.
No worries, but for this gen I do not. I have dropped Doubles since the introductory of Triples, so I came from 6v6 Doubles prior to Gen5 but after Gen3 (DPPtHGSS basically). Was there anything I wrote that seemed off?Kashinn im sorry if this comes off as rude but do you play doubles at all?
yeah this is a bad pokemon why the fuck did you hype it so much celever. the main reason its bad is not because of its stats, movepool, ability or typing; simply the fact that everything it does is outclassed. if i want a fast pokemon with good ground and dragon stab ill choose garchomp, as not only does it have access to the same stab moves, it also has both higher attack and speed stats. if i want a tailwind supporter, ill use salamence, which has significantly better attacking stats and an arguably better typing. all of flygons stats are simply lackluster. 100 attack and speed may seem ok, but almost every physical sweeper that gives it competition has better stats, alongside a better movepool, which makes flygon simply not worth using. it cant even choose to run a special set effectively, as it has a meager 80 special attack, which isnt going to be doing much damage to anything any time soon. leave flygon unranked in my opinion, though i guess it could slip into d.Flygon placement
sorry what. scizor is a great pokemon atm. cant say much that hasnt been said already, but scizor is a really nice utility mon and offensive powerhouse. doesnt really care as much as other mons about intimidate thanks to swords dance and the fact that its primary stabs - bullet punch and bug bite - still fulfill their roles of acting as a useful priority move and being powerful af as well as stealing a berry, respectively. also quite bulky on the physical side, survives surprising hits with relative ease. a weakness to fire is annoying, especially as its probably the best type in doubles right now, but it has no other weaknesses which is awesome, so as long as you avoid the flames you should be cool. scizor should stay in a rank.Scizor dropping from A to B
im really on edge about this one. bisharp is a really cool pokemon and serves a great anti-meta pokemon with nice stabs (especially knock off) and the ability to revenge kill relatively effectively with sucker punch. obviously the best part is defiant, which fucks up anything tryign to lower stats (switching in on gengars shadow ball for spD drop is baller af). sucker punch is seriously a great way to revenge kill threats such as lando-t and shaymin-s, and knock off is a great spammable move that cripples whatever the fuck your opponent wants to bring in (megas can suck a dick). also cress can go die in a hole bisharp destroys it. weakness to common fire, fighting and ground moves alongside low speed and mediocre defensive stats are a downfall, but i feel that bisharps positives outweigh its negatives enough to make it worthy of a rank.Bisharp rising from B to A
You forgot that Diggersby also has STAB priority, hits harder with its STABs than both of them (unless Chomp is Mega) and that it's a lot less predictable.I don't see any reason to use Diggersby over Garchomp or Landorus-T. Also Rain Stall literally does not exist.
Things Landorus-T can do over diggersby
- Intimidate
- Ground immunity
- Fighting resistance
- much more bulk
- More Speed
Things Garchomp can do over diggersby
- Dragon STAB
- Resistances that come with Dragon-typing
- More Speed
- Ability helps keep Kangas in check, and discourages Fake Out
Things Diggersby do over the other mons
- hit a bit harder.
Wouldn't it be best to hold off moving these two on the basis of sleep clause till sleep clause is actually lifted? Even though it will probably be lifted, I don't want to count the chicks before the eggs hatch.Amoonguss: (UP) mostly because of sleep clause probably going away.
Breloom: (UP) same reasoning as Amoonguss. Both belong in A now.
On this topic, I would like to see Whismicott nominated to move down to C rank. I think it's worse than Klefki. No offense too, but worse typing than Klefki. Tailwind instead of Thunder Wave, and whilst Taunt and Encore are great, you can work around them, as you should always suspect them when Whimsicott is out. It's harder to work around them than Screens.Klefki: (DOWN) at least one tier, if not two. Has absolutely no offense, decent typing doesn't make up for it. "Support" should really never be dedicated to an entire Pokemon in doubles.
Mantine: (DOWN) what the hell is this doing here? I love Mantine, don't get me wrong, but I have so many doubts that this is validly a C tier Pokemon. I'm super welcoming to see this thing kick ass, though, so prove me wrong please.
Yea its kind of easy to agree with all of these bolded suggestions. The only one I don't agree with is Deo-A simply because all it has to do is attack once to do its job(kill or significantly cripple one thing) and it can often attack several times due to Sash+Detect and Follow Me/Fake Out support. A bunch of these suspects make sense, but a whooole lot of them are skeptical.Okay, went through the list since I forgot this existed and conjured a list of what caught my eye right away.
Basically, anything I have listed as "suspect" is mostly stuff I haven't tested extensively enough to make an opinion on and feel could be moved up/down (denoted by the letter next to it) based on its general potential. Anything I wrote a description of is what I have tested and feel more strongly about.
Most of the OP list is very good- I know this is expected to be progressive discussion, just wanted to make it clear that although I'm bringing up a slew of Pokemon, I'm not skeptical of the tier list altogether. I'm just bringing up a few subtle changes that I think need to be considered.
Feel free to respond on anything I post here, I'm curious on a lot of the suspect Pokemon. Once SPL is over for me (hopefully not soon!) I'll start testing a bit more with this new stuff, but for now I can only do so much since I have final exams next week plus (hopefully) a playoff match to prepare for.
S-Tier
{suspects: Heatran(D)}
Tyranitar: (DOWN) a little high. A is probably a better fit.
Charizard-Y: (DOWN) pretty much the same as Tyranitar. I can't really give an amazing explanation for each other than that they definitely are not in the same league as Cresselia / Rotom-W / Landorus-T / Kangaskhan
A-Tier
{suspects: Gardevoir(D), Ludicolo(D), Latios(D), Talonflame(D), Togekiss(U)}
Landorus-T: (UP) definitely S-tier, probably the Pokemon I feel most strongly about on this list. The whole "which item does it have?" "is it going to U-Turn?" "is it going to outspeed me?" ("which item does it have?") "is it going to out-damage me?" ("which item does it have?") "if it does U-Turn, what is it going to switch into?" "if it doesn't U-Turn, what is it going to do?" is enough reason the timer is not enough for Smogon Doubles matches. I didn't use this thing in 6/9 of my SPL matches because I liked it aesthetically, I used it because it's borderline broken due to the ridiculous amount of options it gets. If we had to suspect test a Pokemon, this would be my nomination before Kangaskhan, Cresselia, and Heatran.
Rotom-W: (UP) the insane amount of good scenarios this thing can create probably makes it worthy of consideration as an S-tier Pokemon. This and Landorus-T both aren't far-fetched S-Tier Pokemon and both have seen enough successful use for this to be considered.
B-Tier
{suspects: Jirachi(U), Jellicent(U/D), Mew(U/D), Rotom-H(U), Suicune(U), Trevenant(D), Tornadus(D), Thundurus-Therian(U), Goodra(D), Greninja(D), Metagross(D), Sylveon(D)}
Amoonguss: (UP) mostly because of sleep clause probably going away.
Breloom: (UP) same reasoning as Amoonguss. Both belong in A now.
Bisharp: (UP) Knock Off getting buffed makes Bisharp more than the strongest 50/50er in the game.
Deoxys-A: (DOWN) at least one tier, if not two. Biggest gimper ever, no defense, no type synergy.
Klefki: (DOWN) at least one tier, if not two. Has absolutely no offense, decent typing doesn't make up for it. "Support" should really never be dedicated to an entire Pokemon in doubles.
C-Tier
{suspects: Blaziken(U), Aerodactyl(U), Arcanine(U), Porygon2(U), Rhyperior(U), Meowstic(D), Zygarde(D)}
Escavalier: (UP) Drill Run allows it to take care of Heatran inside of Trick Room. I think B is a safe place for Escavalier. It's better than Scizor non-mega, but doesn't have mega potential, so Scizor should probably never be more than a tier ahead of it, and I think moving Escavalier up is safer than moving Scizor down.
Mantine: (DOWN) what the hell is this doing here? I love Mantine, don't get me wrong, but I have so many doubts that this is validly a C tier Pokemon. I'm super welcoming to see this thing kick ass, though, so prove me wrong please.
Torterra: (DOWN) No way. I'm even more skeptical about Torterra than I am about Mantine and I don't know if any convincing could get me to accept Torterra as C tier, much less D tier, much less ahead of Eviolite Grotle (which is probably not even C tier to begin with.)
D-Tier
Why does this tier even exist? I don't know what it's accomplishing other than appeasing potential singles fans (which we want to do, but certainly not with tier lists: the goal here should be to inform!)
Edit: C-Rank for Diggersby and Raikou seems pretty fair, to add to that discussion.